Sports news > Football news > 4.5 million reasons why Scott Brown must show Celtic what all the Hoop-la was about
4.5 million reasons why Scott Brown must show Celtic what all the Hoop-la was about
Gordon Strachan beat Rangers to one of the hottest properies in Scottish football – but the former Hibs star has been a big let-down and will have to perform next season.
by gerald mclaughlin on 02 May 2008
Email this Article (3) Comments
When Celtic beat Rangers in the hunt for £4.5million Scott Brown's signature last summer, any rational Hoops fan was delighted that we had acquired the hottest young Scottish talent going.Much rejoicing and mickey-taking was evident amongst the Bhoys after Rangers dropped out of the chase due to the rising wages being negotiated.Rangers supporters had even been singing, "We’re gonna take Scott Brown," at a match against Hibernian at Easter Road.Oh, how the gloating went on. Oh, how the gloating has subsided into a bit of a whimper.There is no denying the talent of Brown but one must question his aggressive streak and, at times, simple ball control. He made a good start, with boundless energy on show and some man-of-the-match performances alongside Massimo Donati in the middle of the park.However, too many yellow cards and complete vanishing acts in many games started the tongues wagging.Is Celtic’s current formation suitable for Brown’s style of play? Gordon Strachan plays with two wide men every week. Every possible duo in the middle of the park has been tried.Rangers signing of Kevin Thompson, who was Brown’s safety magnet at Hibs, made sure there would be comparisons as to who was adapting to life in an easier fashion at the bigger clubs.It has to be said that Thompson is an extremely vital cog in the Rangers midfield and Brown has struggled to adapt.Is it the pressure? Does Brown need two players with him in the middle of the park? Perhaps, because it seems that Brown doesn’t really know what his job is in the Celtic midfield.Due to the two wide men adopted by Strachan, the middle of the park cries out for a fetching and carrying duo. Much better suited, it would seem, to Barry Robson and Paul Hartley.Brown is far too rash and clumsy in the tackle to be a defensive midfielder, yet he seems unable to make as many lung-bursting runs as he used to. His touch, at times, is appalling for a professional footballer. He seems stifled and confused.Is it the orders from the management team? Are we playing to the strengths of a talented player who was bought to be built around? It’s frustrating for everyone concerned.Strachan has a strange habit of signing players and then asking them to do something completely different. Should these type of plans not be instigated in a steady fashion?With three games left for Celtic, it is highly unlikely that Brown will feature as long as Robson and Hartley stay fit for a nail-biting run-in.A large sum of money was invested in Brown and there are no doubts that he will be used and relied on heavily next year. It is of paramount importance that Strachan, Brown and Celtic work out some way for him to showcase his skills to the maximum.Brown will move on in a couple of years and Celtic will be looking to make at least double what they paid for him. On current form, that is unlikely but Brown has youth on his side and a valued reputation throughout Britain. It would be a shame to discover that he failed to fulfill the potential.He is a solid lad and does not involve himself in any shenanigans outside of the football world. Perhaps the jump to Parkhead affected him in more ways than even he expected.The players and fans know how much talent Brown has and, in a debut season, glimpses of skill coupled with a surprisingly tolerant support have not led to full-scale criticism of the young Scot.Unfortunately, if Brown thought that this year was a pressure cooker, then if a marked improvement is not made next season and he still fails to get among the goals, then he may suffer the full force of the Celtic crowd.Let’s hope, for Scotland’s sake also, that this is not the case. Good luck, Scott Brown.
Comments (3)
by Simon Taylor on May 02, 2008
It is no secret he is a Rangers fan (we all know that), also that he was willing to go to us for the larger wage packet (greedy) & i heard Davie Provan say on Radio Clyde that he is , quote, "hard work" in & around Celtic Park for the staff who are trying to help him. Provan added that he has been told by a coach of another SPL club (he wouldn't out the guy) but said believe me Scott Brown still wants to play for Rangers & is missing his midfield buddy & best mate off the park Kevin Thomson. So he is a sulking, moody, greedy, not very bright young man who has been crap for 4.5 mill. I think his old gaffer & boss of newly promoted West Brom will be watching this boring saga unfold. Tony Mowbray.
by Danny P on May 02, 2008
Charlatan, you wouldnt happen to phone radio clyde a few times a week, and after picking up the daily record and reading another huggh keevins exclusive, run around to your pals and everyone else telling them that you know things for a fact (but neglect to mention where it came from) Both Kevin Thomson and Scott Brown puplicly said they wanted to play for Celtic, well before bids were accepted and wages were negotiated. Thomson wanted to come to Celtic, Celtic dropped out of the bidding, because the previously negotiated fee for the two of them, suddenly became the fee for Scott Brown. Individually Celtic felt that £2m+ way over the odds for Thomson, leaving Thomson with the option of signing for Rangers, or staying with Hibs. You have just bleated out a load of nonsense in my opinion and most other sane Celtic supporters, even insinuating that his form is down to a desire to play for Rangers. There are many reasons his form could be attribured to, some may be true, some may not, it also may be a little bit of each. Not having a regular midfield partner, not having a defensive midfield partner (asking Hartley to do it, is like asking Lennon to do the attacking midfield role, because we had Lambert), the pressure of having to win every game, the pressure that comes from losing the ball once, having an atrocious defence behind him, having no one moving off the ball, one striker who is immobile... As i said, it could be one of, or some of many things. Look at Alan Stubbs, shocking 1st season, no one could put the finger on how this supposed future english international, who Fegus McCann would have parted with £3.75 of his millions into buying, could be so bad... 2nd season, and the rest is history Give the lad a chance (and Donati for that matter) Lets have this chat at this stage next season
by J on May 03, 2008
DannyBhoy - Neither Thomson or Brown publicly said they wanted to play for Celtic. There agent said that, and given their agents track record, I wouldn't trust him to look after my dog. When Thomson signed for Rangers he made it perfectly clearly who he was wanting to sign off. Quite glad we did because he has shown why he was captain of Hibs, and has left Brown in his shadow.
Add your comment here
PERSONAL ABUSE WILL NOT BE TOLERATED
First Name
Display your favourite sport or football team badge with your comment.
Last Name
Sport
Email
League
Heading
Team
Comment *
Please enter the text you see in the picture into the textbox below. *
<a href="http://adserver.adtech.de/adlink|3.0|327|1632896|0|170|ADTECH;loc=300;key=key1+key2+key3+key4;sub1=[subst]" mce_href="http://adserver.adtech.de/adlink|3.0|327|1632896|0|170|ADTECH;loc=300;key=key1+key2+key3+key4;sub1=[subst]" target="_blank"><img src="http://adserver.adtech.de/adserv|3.0|327|1632896|0|170|ADTECH;loc=300;key=key1+key2+key3+key4" mce_src="http://adserver.adtech.de/adserv|3.0|327|1632896|0|170|ADTECH;loc=300;key=key1+key2+key3+key4" border="0" width="300" height="250"></a>
Revealed: The reality of England's World Cup problems - and Premier League quotas
Sri Lanka v India: Mendis the young pretender faces the Tendulkar Test
Can Novak Djokovic come back from his early Wimbledon exit to become world No.1?
Arsenal Aston Villa Barcelona Chelsea Everton Football Liverpool Manchester City Manchester United Newcastle United Portsmouth Real Madrid Sunderland Tottenham Hotspur West Ham United